Chicago Dog Pie
A creation so unfortunate, it has never been seen on the internet before. I asked the question “what if you could have a Chicago hot dog - but still have it compete in a pie competion?”.

π₯ Awards π︎
As I don’t enjoy baking in any form, I knew I’d only be able to compete on shock & humor factors. This recipe ended up outdoing my wildest dreams for it.
This pie won not one, but TWO categories at the March 2026 pie competition it was a part of. With 17 total taste testers & voters, it came out with the awards for “Funniest Pie” and “Breaking the Tin - the pie that deviates most from tradition”.
Thanks to all my haters, see you next year with the Mallort pie (if I keep the Chicago angle).
Ingredients π︎
- frozen deep pie crust
- all beef hot dogs
- eggs & cheese (to hold all the pieces of hot dog together)
- toppings:
- white onion
- sport peppers
- pickle spears
- tomato slices
How to make it π︎
- Chop up all the hot dogs into coins
- Make a mixture of 1-2 eggs + a dash of milk per pie
- Fill the pie tin with the dogs first, and add egg mix on top
- Bake at 375 degrees for 40 minutes
- While it’s baking, chop up the toppings
- Let it cool a bit
- Add all the toppings once it’s ready to be served, since they are normally served room temp on a ‘dog.
What it didn’t have π︎
Before my detractors come for me, it is not a true Chicago dog. I was missing the poppy seed bun and had the wrong relish, but I decided that I didn’t care enough to chase perfectionism with this experiment.